Top 5 Best Cream Eyeshadows 2024

Cream eyeshadows are a popular choice for those who want a quick and easy eye makeup look. They are easy to apply and blend, making them perfect for both beginners and experts. Cream eyeshadows come in a variety of shades and finishes, from matte to shimmer, making them a versatile product for any makeup look.

When it comes to cream eyeshadows, the critical thing to pay attention to is the formula. A good cream eyeshadow should be long-lasting, crease-resistant, and easy to blend. The texture should be smooth and creamy, allowing for easy application without any tugging or pulling on the delicate eye area.

We spent hours researching and testing ten different cream eyeshadows to identify the best ones on the market. From drugstore to high-end options, we tested for pigmentation, blendability, longevity, and overall performance.

After our extensive testing, we have narrowed down the top cream eyeshadows that are worth your investment. Whether you’re looking for a natural everyday look or a bold and dramatic eye, we’ve got you covered.

Best Cream Eyeshadows

Looking for a cream eyeshadow that will give you that perfect shimmery look? Look no further than our roundup of the best cream eyeshadows on Amazon. We have tested and reviewed a variety of cream eyeshadows to bring you our top picks. Whether you’re looking for a long-lasting formula or a wide range of colors, we’ve got you covered. Check out our list below to find the perfect cream eyeshadow for you.

Revlon ColorStay Crème Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a long-lasting, highly pigmented cream eyeshadow, the Revlon ColorStay Crème Eye Shadow is definitely worth considering.

Pros

• The creamy formula is easy to blend and goes on smoothly, making it perfect for both lid and lash line application.
• With a choice of 18 gorgeous shades in both matte and shimmer finishes, it’s easy to find the perfect color for any occasion.
• The waterproof, longwear formula lasts up to 24 hours without smudging or fading, making it perfect for all-day wear.

Cons

• While the built-in brush is handy for on-the-go application, some users may prefer to use their own brushes for more precise application.
• The formula can be a little thick, so it’s important to use a light touch when applying to avoid a heavy, cakey look.
• Some users may find that the formula creases slightly after several hours of wear.

Overall, we think the Revlon ColorStay Crème Eye Shadow is a great choice for anyone looking for a high-quality cream eyeshadow that will last all day. With its smooth, blendable formula and long-lasting wear, it’s sure to become a staple in your makeup collection.

Revlon Crème Eyeshadow, ColorStay 24 Hour Eye Makeup, Highly Pigmented Cream Formula in Blendable Matte & Shimmer Finishes, 715 Espresso, 0.18 Oz

Check Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a long-lasting and highly pigmented cream eyeshadow, Revlon Crème Eyeshadow is definitely worth considering.

Pros

• The smooth and blendable formula makes it easy to apply and create different looks.
• The matte and shimmer finishes offer versatility and allow you to customize your makeup look.
• The waterproof and longwear formula ensures that your eye makeup stays put for up to 24 hours.

Cons

• The built-in shadow brush may not be suitable for everyone’s preferences and may require additional blending with your fingertips or a separate brush.
• The cream eyeshadow may feel a bit heavy on the eyelids for some users.
• The limited shade range may not cater to everyone’s preferences.

We’ve tried the Revlon Crème Eyeshadow in Espresso, and we were impressed with how easy it was to apply and blend. The formula glided on smoothly and stayed put throughout the day without smudging or creasing. We also appreciated the versatility of the matte and shimmer finishes, which allowed us to create different looks depending on the occasion. However, we found that the built-in shadow brush was not our favorite and required additional blending with our fingertips. Additionally, the cream eyeshadow felt a bit heavy on our eyelids, which may not be suitable for everyone’s preferences. Overall, we think that the Revlon Crème Eyeshadow is a great option for those looking for a long-lasting and highly pigmented cream eyeshadow.

Burt’s Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a natural and nourishing cream eyeshadow that can multitask as a highlighter, Burt’s Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow is a great option.

Pros

• The lightweight and creamy formula applies smoothly and blends easily with your fingertips, making it perfect for on-the-go application.
• The shimmery, creamy pigments can be worn on their own, as a highlighter, or layered with powder eyeshadow to achieve the desired intensity.
• The eye shadow is formulated with nourishing ingredients like Vitamin E and Berry Fruit Wax, and is packed with rich, light-reflecting pearl pigments.

Cons

• Some users have reported that the color tends towards orange rather than rose, which may not be suitable for everyone.
• A few users have experienced allergic reactions to the eye shadow.
• The product may dry out and crack during shipping, which could affect its texture and quality.

In our experience, Burt’s Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow is a great option for those looking for a natural and nourishing cream eyeshadow. The lightweight and creamy formula applies smoothly and blends easily with your fingertips, making it perfect for on-the-go application. The shimmery, creamy pigments can be worn on their own, as a highlighter, or layered with powder eyeshadow to achieve the desired intensity. The eye shadow is formulated with nourishing ingredients like Vitamin E and Berry Fruit Wax, and is packed with rich, light-reflecting pearl pigments. However, some users have reported that the color tends towards orange rather than rose, which may not be suitable for everyone. Additionally, a few users have experienced allergic reactions to the eye shadow. Finally, the product may dry out and crack during shipping, which could affect its texture and quality. Overall, we think that Burt’s Bees Color Nurture Cream Eye Shadow is a great option for those looking for a natural and nourishing cream eyeshadow.

e.l.f. No Budge Cream Eyeshadow

Check Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a versatile cream eyeshadow that can be used as a primer and liner, e.l.f. No Budge Cream Eyeshadow is a great option. It’s easy to apply, has a creamy formula, and delivers long-lasting color that’s smudge- and crease-resistant.

Pros

• The 3-in-1 formula is a great value and saves time in your makeup routine.
• The creamy texture is easy to blend and buildable for a range of looks.
• The product is vegan, cruelty-free, and free from harmful toxins.

Cons

• Some users may find the formula too thick or heavy for their liking.
• The color range may not be extensive enough for some users.
• The product may dry out quickly if not stored properly.

We found that the e.l.f. No Budge Cream Eyeshadow is an excellent multi-use product that’s perfect for all skin types. The creamy texture glides over the lids easily, and the color stays put all day without fading, smudging, or creasing.

We recommend using your fingertips or a brush to apply the product, and allowing it to set before applying more color. The product is available in eight long-lasting colors that range from essential to vibrant, making it easy to find the perfect shade for your style.

Overall, we think the e.l.f. No Budge Cream Eyeshadow is a great option for anyone looking for a versatile, long-lasting eyeshadow that’s easy to apply and buildable.

wet n wild Color Icon Cream Eyeshadow Makeup Multi-Stick Champagne Room

Check Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a versatile, long-lasting cream eyeshadow, the wet n wild Color Icon Cream Eyeshadow Makeup Multi-Stick Champagne Room might be a great choice for you.

Pros

• This cream-to-powder formula is velvety and multifunctional, so you can use it on your eyes, cheeks, and lips.
• The silky formula glides on and blends into skin effortlessly, making it easy to apply even if you’re in a hurry.
• Infused with nourishing Passion Fruit seed, Argan oils, and Vitamin E, this cream eyeshadow stick helps moisturize and nourish your skin.

Cons

• Some users might find the shade range too limited, especially if they prefer brighter or bolder colors.
• The formula might crease or smudge if you have oily eyelids or if you don’t use a primer.
• The packaging might be a bit flimsy, so you’ll need to be careful when handling the stick to avoid breaking it.

Overall, we think the wet n wild Color Icon Cream Eyeshadow Makeup Multi-Stick Champagne Room is a great option if you’re looking for a multitasking cream eyeshadow that’s easy to apply and blend. The formula is smooth and silky, and the shade range includes both matte and metallic finishes. However, if you’re looking for very bright or bold colors, you might need to look for other options.

Buying Guide

When it comes to buying cream eyeshadows, there are a few things to keep in mind to ensure you get the best product for your needs. Here are some features to consider when choosing a cream eyeshadow:

Texture and Consistency

The texture and consistency of a cream eyeshadow can greatly affect its application and wear time. Look for a product that has a smooth and creamy texture that glides easily onto your eyelids. Avoid products that are too thick or too thin, as they can be difficult to apply evenly and may crease or smudge throughout the day.

Pigmentation

The pigmentation of a cream eyeshadow is another important factor to consider. Look for a product that has rich and vibrant color payoff, as this will ensure that your eyeshadow looks bold and beautiful all day long. Avoid products that are too sheer or require multiple layers to achieve the desired color intensity.

Longevity

Longevity is key when it comes to cream eyeshadows. Look for a product that is long-wearing and can withstand the heat and humidity of the day. Avoid products that smudge or crease easily, as this can ruin your entire eye makeup look.

Finish

The finish of a cream eyeshadow can greatly affect the overall look of your eye makeup. Look for a product that has a finish that complements your skin tone and eye shape. Matte finishes are great for creating a natural and subtle look, while shimmery and metallic finishes are perfect for adding a pop of glamour and sparkle.

Packaging

Packaging is often overlooked when it comes to cream eyeshadows, but it can make a big difference in the overall user experience. Look for a product that comes in a hygienic and convenient packaging, such as a tube or a jar with a pump. Avoid products that come in bulky or hard-to-use packaging, as this can make application difficult and messy.

By considering these features, you can choose the best cream eyeshadow for your needs and achieve a flawless eye makeup look every time.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the top cream eyeshadows recommended for mature skin?

Cream eyeshadows are a great option for mature skin as they are less likely to settle into fine lines and wrinkles. Some of the top cream eyeshadows recommended for mature skin are the Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadows, the Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow Sticks, and the Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eye Colour.

Which drugstore cream eyeshadows offer the best quality?

Drugstore cream eyeshadows have come a long way in terms of quality and performance. Some of the best drugstore cream eyeshadows include the Maybelline Color Tattoo 24HR Cream Gel Eyeshadows, the L’Oreal Paris Infallible 24HR Eye Shadow, and the Revlon ColorStay Creme Eye Shadow.

Can you suggest a cream eyeshadow palette with versatile options?

If you’re looking for a cream eyeshadow palette with versatile options, we recommend the Stila Eyes Are the Window Shadow Palette in Soul. This palette features a range of neutral shades that can be used for both day and night looks.

What cream eyeshadows are suitable for sensitive eyes?

For those with sensitive eyes, it’s important to look for cream eyeshadows that are fragrance-free and hypoallergenic. Some of the best cream eyeshadows for sensitive eyes include the Clinique Lid Pop, the Tarte Sea Breezy Cream Shadow, and the BareMinerals Gen Nude Eyeshadow + Primer.

How do cream-to-powder eyeshadows perform compared to traditional creams?

Cream-to-powder eyeshadows offer the best of both worlds as they provide the ease of application of cream eyeshadows with the long-wear and crease-resistant properties of powder eyeshadows. They tend to have a more matte finish compared to traditional creams. Some great cream-to-powder eyeshadows include the Nudestix Magnetic Luminous Eye Color and the Kaja Beauty Bento Bouncy Shimmer Eyeshadow Trio.

What shades of eyeshadow tend to be more flattering for aging eyes?

Neutral shades tend to be the most flattering for aging eyes as they can help brighten and lift the eye area. Taupe, beige, and soft brown shades are great options. Avoid using dark or harsh colors as they can make the eyes appear smaller and more tired.

We independently select all products and services. This article was written by a third-party company. If you click through links we provide, we may earn a commission.