There are some beauty trends that are as classic as a white, buttoned blouse. And that, my dahlings, is the perfect winged eyeliner. The very best eyeliners are those that help you paint a sharp, clean line with minimal effort. (Oh, and bonus points if it’s blacker-than-black.)
To make it easier to find the perfect eyeliner—whether you swipe it straight across your lids or opt for an angled line à la Amy Winehouse or Cleopatra—we’ve scoured the internet for our favorites. Ahead, the best eyeliners with glowing reviews on Amazon and Influenster—which may or may not be sharp enough to kill a man.
The best-reviewed eyeliners
The best eyeliner with glam eyelash growth serum
The Lavish Liner by Hairgenics Pronexa comes with a felt tip that makes it easy to fan out your line in one fell swoop. Bonus, the formula includes a botanical eyelash growth enhancing serum, biotin, and castor oil to grow thicker lashes.
The best eyeliner for getting pro cat-eye wings
If you’ve ever struggled to get your winged tips to match in length and size, the Eyeliner Stamp Wingliner by Lovoir is for you. It’s designed to make each winged tip as identical as possible. Each pen comes with a “stamp” end that helps you draw a quick cat-eye line while the other end of the pen helps you perfect the line.
The best eyeliner for drawing flexible lines
The Rimmel Glam Eyes liquid eyeliner has become a fan-favorite, thanks to the smudge-proof formula and flexible tip. Use it to draw thin or thick winged, looks.
The best eyeliner with long-lasting power
If you prefer to carefully build up your eyeliner line, consider using a gel pot like the L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner. The formula is designed to last 24-hours and it leaves a high-glossy finish that’s perfect for thicker wings.
The best eyeliner for when you need to stock up
The NYC Liquid Eyeliner comes with a very thin brush applicator, making it ideal for those who’ve perfected their skills. (I.e., no beginners.) It’s also cheaper than most other eyeliners (and you can buy it in packs of four on Amazon). It may not have quite the lasting power of some others on this list, but it’ll get your through the workday.
The best eyeliner for a blacker-than-black line
The Absolute New York Liquid Eyeliner is color-dispensing pen with a bold shade of black ink. You might have to shake it a few times to get all the color out, but reviewers on Amazon love the final result.
The best eyeliner that’s also water-proof
The NYX Docolor Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner comes with a thin, felt-tip applicator pen that Amazon reviewers praise for its ability to easily glide on eyelids. The pointed tip also makes it easy to draw a very, very slim line across lashes for a minimal look. Oh, and it’s waterproof! So, bring on the waterworks.
The best eyeliner that’s vegan and cruelty-free
The Zuzu Luxe Liquid Eyeliner has a smaller tip applicator to draw your line in short strokes. If you’re afraid of messing up with one fell swoop, this one will allow you to carefully build the look you want. And, like other Zuzu products, its formula is vegan.
The best budget eyeliner for a professional look
If you’re looking for a budget-friendly, drugstore eyeliner, consider the NYX Matte Liquid Eyeliner. At just $7, the liquid eyeliner comes with a longer tip applicator and a small pot of ink you can dip into for just the right amount of pigment.
The best eyeliner with multiple color options
If black eyeliner every day sounds a little boring to you, then look for an eyeliner formula with multiple color options. Reviewers on Influenster love the Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner, which is available in 12 color shades, from black to deep blue to emerald green.